What would cause a manual transmission to not shift

My Manual Transmission Is Hard To Shift Into First And Reverse, Why?

What would cause a manual transmission to not shift

It's hard to shift into first and reverse because the clutch is not working properly. The purpose of the clutch is to disconnect the transmission from the spinning engine. When you depress the clutch pedal, the friction portion of the clutch (clutch disc) is allowed to move away from the turning flywheel which is spinning with the engine's crankshaft. When the clutch is no longer touching the flywheel, the gears in the transmission slow down or stop moving and normal shifting into first or reverse takes place.

Hard, and sometimes impossible shifting into first and reverse is caused by the clutch disc not moving away from the spinning flywheel. This is commonly referred to as the "clutch is not releasing". The number one cause is the hydraulic system that operates the clutch is leaking and has low fluid. Check the level in the clutch's master cylinder mounted on the firewall and add brake fluid if it is low and get it checked out.

Another cause of a shifting problem is the pressure assembly, also called a pressure plate, is simply wearing out. The pressure assembly actually traps the clutch disc between itself and the flywheel when the clutch pedal is not depressed and releases the clutch disc when depressed. Age and miles cause the springs in the pressure plate to fatigue and usually requires a complete clutch job.

What would cause a manual transmission to not shift

Jupiterimages/Photos.com/Getty Images

Automatic transmissions are more common these days, but for people who still enjoy the hands-on approach, a manual, or standard, transmission can present a few problems. Your car's engine transfers power to the transmission via a clutch. Sector forks in the transmission select which gear will be put into use. Although there are components to prevent gears from grinding or sticking, sometimes gears do fail to engage. If this happens, there are a number of things to look for before talking to a mechanic.

Step 1

Check your transmission fluid. Transmission fluid lubricates the moving parts of your transmission. You should check your fluid every 30,000 to 60,000 miles in a manual transmission car. Failure to do so can cause your transmission fluid to become contaminated with bits of metal from the bearings, synchronizers and gears. This can make shifting difficult or impossible. Because transmissions give few signals when their fluid is low, it's important to be consistent about checking it. You may also need to upgrade to a different type of fluid if you find that your transmission problems are happening during cold weather, or if you are using a fluid not originally recommended for your vehicle.

Step 2

Listen for gear clashing and grinding. Grinding gears will result in a grating sound as you shift between gears. If this is the case, the trouble may be in your synchronizers. Sychronizers are positioned between the two main drive gears and are responsible for locking the gears into the correct speed with the engine. Synchro rings that match the width and depth of the gears on the main shaft can also become worn or bent. Once this happens, your car may fail to shift.

Step 3

If your transmission cannot be put into gear when the car is running but you can change gears with the engine off, the problem could be with your pressure plate or clutch disk. Your clutch disk should be checked every 15,000 miles (or less if you engage in stop and go, city driving). There is no way to determine if your pressure plate or clutch disk are bad without dismantling the bell housing of the transmission. If you suspect either are worn, it's probably best to replace them.

Step 4

If your clutch engages close to the floor, or if it moves easily but does not allow you to shift, the clutch linkage may have become disconnected or the clutch cable may have snapped. Worn clutch pedal bushings will cause the same problems. Check with your mechanic to determine if you need to replace the entire clutch assembly or individual components of the clutch.

References

Writer Bio

Terry Hollis began writing professionally in 1999. His work has appeared in "Dance Insider Magazine," on BLARE.com and for short story readings at Emory University in Atlanta, where he now lives. He received his Bachelor of Arts in international studies from Morehouse College.

By Tsukasa Azuma

Last updated Feb 01, 2021

0 comments

The transmission of a car controls the transfer of power from the engine to the driveshaft. It’s a complex mechanical system that is more susceptible to wear and tear than other components because of the huge amount of friction and heat it has to endure. Even a well-maintained gearbox is likely to undergo problems depending on your driving habit, mileage, and some other related factors. One such problem is manual transmission won’t go into gear when running.

Manual Transmission Won’t Go into Gear When Running: The Symptoms

Any repair or replacement of the transmission components are inconvenient, time-consuming, and requires a handsome amount of money. So, you should be on alert for unusual activities to detect a glitch at the primary stage.

What would cause a manual transmission to not shift
The car will make a grinding sound during this problem. Source: Top Speed

When the transmission won’t shift gears despite the engine is running, you should immediately have it diagnosed by an expert mechanic. The signs that the car will show at this time are:

  • The transmission won’t shift and the car makes a grinding sound when the engine is running. Besides, pulling out of first gear will feel harder than normal.
  • The transmission will shift in and out of gear without any issue when the car is not running.
  • It won’t come out of the reverse gear when the car is running.
  • You can push the clutch to the limit but the engine almost halts upon allowing the clutch out.

SEE MORE:

  • Is It Possible to Drive without ransmission Fluid?
  • Things You Should Know about 4-Speed Automatic Transmission

The Reasons for Manual Transmission Won’t Go into Gear When Running

There are some specific reasons for the manual transmission to behave in that way. Let’s check if your car is having issues in these areas:

Look into the clutch.

The problem could be the result of a stubborn clutch refusing to disengage. The one way of checking it is to start the car after engaging the gear and clutch. If the vehicle stumbles forward, you should take it to a servicing shop. An experienced mechanic should diagnose the clutch system because it indicates that the hydraulic clutch not putting any pressure on the pressure plate.

Be careful not to do the clutch testing in a busy area. The car will lurch forward suddenly when you turn on the engine. So, choose a vacant place where there is no chance to hit anything or anybody.

What would cause a manual transmission to not shift
A stubborn clutch is a symptom of this problem. Source: Car Throttle

Low level of transmission fluid.

The components in modern manual transmission are always in motion even when the gears are in neutral. If there is no lubricant in the gearbox, you could have done major damage to the engine and gearbox components by running the car. You could end up with an expensive repair and even replacement of the whole transmission system.

Conclusion

The best way to stay away from transmission problems is to follow the recommended maintenance schedule and regular checkup procedures. A well-maintained transmission will perform better and have a longer lifespan.

How do you troubleshoot a manual transmission that will not shift?

Press the Clutch Pedal Down More. If you have a manual transmission, try to press the clutch pedal all the way down to the floor before trying to change gears. ... .
Check the Transmission Fluid Levels. Before you do anything else, you'll want to check your transmission fluid levels. ... .
Look at the Linkage Going to the Shifter..

What can cause a manual transmission to not go in gear?

Top 8 Reasons Your Car Won't Go Into Gear.
Clutch Issues. ... .
Brake Safety Lock Issues. ... .
Transmission Fluid Problems. ... .
Loose or Broken Shift Linkage Wire. ... .
Bad Torque Converter. ... .
Bad Transmission. ... .
Failing Clutch Packs. ... .
Misaligned Gearbox..

Why is my manual not shifting?

The most common reason why a manual transmission is hard to shift is due to a faulty clutch or hydraulic clutch system. It can also be damage to the gearbox, like damaged gears or faulty synchronizer rings. Check the gearbox fluid level, since it could also cause shifting issues.